The Reverend Thomas Phillips
(April 1866 – December 1870)
The Reverend A. Webster (January 1873 – January 1874)
The Reverend R.F. Blakeley (January 1874 – January 1875)
The Reverend Thomas Phillips (January 1875 – January 1878)
The Reverend Abrams Middleton (January 1878- January 1879)
The Reverend E. M. Pinckney (January 1879 – January 1881)
The Reverend Vincent Henry Buckley (January 1881 – January 1883)
The Reverend D.M. Minus (January 1883 – 1886)
The Reverend Isaac Nunez Cardozo (January 1886 – January 1889)
The Reverend James Richard Townsend (January 1989 – February 1891)
The Reverend J. L. Grice (February 1891 – January 1896)
The Reverend W. M. Hanna (January 1896 – December 1897)
The Reverend J. D. Whittaker (December 1897 – December 1900)
The Reverend T. J. Clark (December 1900 – December 1902)
The Reverend J. B. Taylor (December 1902 – November 1903)
The Reverend J. B. Middleton (November 1903 – December 1904)
The Reverend Isaiah Henry Fulton (December 1904 – November 1907)
The Reverend Addison Evans Quick (November 1907 – November 1911)
The Reverend James Franklin Page (November 1911 – November 1914)
The Reverend R. L. Hickson (November 1914 – November 1916)
The Reverend Lexington G. Gregg (November 1916 – December 1919)
The Reverend A. S. Cottingham (December 1919 – December 1921)
The Reverend W. M. Hanna (December 1921 – December 1924)
The Reverend R. F. Freeman (December 1924 – December 1932)
The Reverend Robert Franklin Harrington (December 1932 – December 1934)
The Reverend M. McCallum (December 1934 – December 1938)
The Reverend Wilbur Russell Gregg (December 1938 – November 1942)
The Reverend I. DeQuincy Newman (November 1942 – October 1950)
The Reverend M. D. McCollom (October 1950 – May 1962)
The Reverend James W. Curry (May 1962 – June 1965)
The Reverend James W. Bradley (June 1974 – June 1978)
The Reverend John D. Boone (June 1978 – June 1982)
The Reverend Doctor George W. Watson (June 1983 – May 1988)
The Reverend George F. Manigo (June 1992 – June 2001)
The Reverend Doctor Ernest W. Etheredge (2001 – 2003)
The Reverend Larry McCutcheon (2004 – June 2015)
All information not verified.